Wine Ratings Explained (2025): The Ultimate Guide to RP, WS, JS & 20+ Top Critics’ Scores—What They Mean and How to Use Them

“92 JS” on a wine list or shelf talker refers to 92 out of a possible 100 points given by reviewer James Suckling of JamesSuckling.com.

Decoding Wine Score Initials: Your Quick Guide

Walk into any wine store and you’ll spot small letters next to numbers: 91 RP, 95 WS, 90 WE. But what do those initials mean—and why should you care?

A Brief History of Wine Ratings

Wine scoring evolved from 20‑point scales into the now-standard 50–100 format. This change was popularized in 1978 by American critic Robert M. Parker Jr. through The Wine Advocate, giving birth to the iconic “Parker points.” This system revolutionized wine evaluation by providing an objective-seeming measure consumers could easily understand. *I will link to any wine media outlets mentioned in this post below.

Advantages include instant consumer guidance, marketing appeal, and potential investment insight. However, critics note that palate bias, systemic influence (often called “Parkerization”), and oversimplification can skew both taste and production practices.

How Wine Critics Score

Most major critics use blind tastings grouped by variety or vintage. They evaluate appearance, aroma, flavor, and overall quality before assigning a score—typically between 50 and 100. Even with similar scales, scoring styles vary: Wine Spectator relies on contextual blind flights, whereas Parker famously includes his emotional response in scoring.

Wine scores can help inform buying decisions with detailed “drink by” dates and cellar suggestions.

Common Score Initials & Who’s Behind Them

• RP = Robert Parker

  Legendary American critic who introduced the 100‑point scale via The Wine Advocate. (www.robertparker.com)

• WA = Wine Advocate

  Parker’s flagship publication, started in 1978 with ~12,000 reviews annually. (see above)

• WS = Wine Spectator

  Established in 1976 as print magazine; conducts blind tastings and reviews roughly 15,000 wines yearly. Yearly Top 100 List. (www.winespectator.com)

• WE = Wine Enthusiast

  Combines accessible ratings with cultural commentary. Started as print magazine. (www.wineenthusiast.com)

• D = Decanter

• Leading UK wine authority offering international scores and analysis. (www.decanter.com)

• JS = James Suckling

  Former Wine Spectator senior editor turned independent critic. (www.jamessuckling.com)

• BH = Burghound (Allen Meadows)

  Premier Burgundy specialist publication. (www.burghound.com)

• BTI = Beverage Testing Institute

  Chicago-based panel producing global ratings. Brands pay to be reviewed and scored. (bevtest.com)

• GR = Gambero Rosso

  Iconic Italian brand awarding “Tre Bicchieri” (“Three Glasses”) to top wines. (www.gamberorossointernational.com)

• JD = Jeb Dunnuck

  Ex-Wine Advocate critic, now influential independent. (jebdunnuck.com)

• ST = Stephen Tanzer

  Founder of International Wine Cellar, later a key voice at Vinous. (x.com/stephentanzer1)

• V = Vinous

  Ex-Wine Advocate critic Antonio Galloni’s wine media platform, continuing IWC-style coverage. (vinous.com)

• W&S = Wine & Spirits Magazine

  Annual Top 100 lists and curated tasting coverage. (www.wineandspiritsmagazine.com)

Bonus forum abbreviations (from enthusiast boards): IWC = International Wine Cellar (old Tanzer); CT = CellarTracker (www.cellartracker.com)

Do Wine Ratings Matter? Yes and No.

For many, points next to initials simplify decision-making but they aren’t a guarantee. A high score can boost shelf presence and even price, yet such ratings reflect individual palates and may not align with your taste. Nothing beats finding a boutique, locally run wine shop staffed by true enthusiasts - they will take the time to learn your palate and make recommendations based on your preferences and their knowledge.

• Match critics to your style. Explore multiple scores—don’t rely on just one.

• Read tasting notes. They reveal nuances behind the number.

• Trust your palate. Use scores as guides, not gospel.

• Think back to high school, when sometimes even the low 80s were acceptable ;)

Wine scores (and the initials next to them) signal opinions from influential voices in wine. By decoding who’s who, understanding scoring methods, and noticing potential biases, consumers can make smarter, more satisfying wine choices.

Want wine-centric knowledge sent straight to your inbox? Sign up for our wine insider newsletter.